image of changing pad and cloth diapers

Considering the environment when choosing diapers

Dear Sam,

My daughter is pregnant with her first child, and my wife and I could not be more excited to welcome our second grandson into the world. But this got us thinking about what is best for the environment: A diaper service that uses reusable cloth diapers, disposable diapers, or wash-at-home diapers?

Sincerely,

Mark

———-

Dear Mark,

Congratulations as you anticipate your second grandchild. In general, a diaper service (reusable cloth diapers collected and washed in bulk by a service) is the best option for the environment, but many factors impact this, such as water conservation and the geographic and financial accessibility of options.

Let’s consider the environmental pros and cons of each of the options available in the Twin Cities area.

Disposable Diapers

Downside: Disposable diapers are a large contributor to landfill and incinerator waste. Around 4.1 million tons of disposable diaper waste (including adult incontinence products) were generated in the U.S. in 2018, according to the EPA’s most recent available data, a figure that has doubled since 1980. In Minneapolis (and in parts of Hennepin County), disposable diapers are burned along with the rest of our residential trash at the incinerator downtown, adding to the volume of plastic trash being burned next to our neighbors in the North Loop and North Minneapolis.

Upside (Minor): Disposable diapers made with plant-based, chlorine-free, and biodegradable materials have a lower environmental impact than those made of conventional petroleum-based plastics. However, the benefit is outweighed by the environmental impacts of the disposal issues mentioned above.  

Cloth Diapers (Home Washed)

Downside: Cloth diapers can be resource-intensive if washed inefficiently (hot water, multiple cycles, frequent loads) and dried on high heat, potentially using more water and energy than disposables.

Upside (Maximized): Buying secondhand cloth diapers, washing in full loads with cold water, and line-drying rather than using a clothes dryer can save money and help minimize environmental impact.

Diaper Services (Cloth)

The Sweet Spot: Using a diaper service offers the benefits of cloth without the laundry hassle, while significantly reducing diaper waste sent to landfills or incinerators.

Upside: Services use bulk washing and efficient machines, often saving water and energy compared to individual home washing, making them an excellent choice, especially in water-scarce areas.

Downside: Access and cost can be drawbacks, depending on where a family lives or what their diaper budget is.

Overall, a diaper service offers a significant environmental advantage by minimizing waste going to landfills and incinerators and optimizing resource use through bulk washing, making it a top choice for sustainability without the burden of home laundry. For those washing at home, smart practices like buying used cloth diapers and cold-washing them can make them greener than disposables. But make sure you use soaps that are strong enough to handle the sanitation requirements in cold water AND gentle enough for your baby’s skin.

Sustainably,

Sam